What the state creates, it can destroy--marriage

I have no idea who Marie Dean is, but on several occasion this commenter at blogs has made a lot of sense.  Most likely a Catholic, this is Dean’s take on the so-called gay or same sex marriage. From comments on other topics, I would guess Dean teaches history.

“The state regulation of marriage began in the Protestant Reformation, a legal movement in the 18th century gaining momentum in the 19th century, with laws in England, Scotland, Switzerland, France and then Germany demanding State recognized marriages rather than Canon Law ones as previously regulated under the Catholic Church. What these laws did was give power to the State to determine the definition of marriage, rather than the Church, allowing for the State, therefore, to change the definition of marriage at will. Civil ceremonies were more common in the French Republic and under Napoleon, as religious or sacramental marriages were not recognized by the State, for example. In England today, a religious marriage is not recognized by law without a civil marriage.

What this did was undermine any moral position of marriage, as once marriage was divorced, pun intended, from religion, anything civil definition could be manipulated.

It is only in the 20th and 21st centuries that we see the logical consequences of separating marriage from a religious sacramental act and merely becoming one more cog in the societal wheel. That such gross aberrations did not happen before the mid-20th century merely points to the fact that there was an overlay of Christianity in the culture. Once that disappeared, the State did what it always wanted to do, define marriage outside that Christian moral framework.

The California law would be in keeping with the logical progress of the undermining of the sacredness of marriage begun back in 1753. Even if the state required a religious setting, as in England at that date, it was the State deciding, creating the law, not God. What the State can create, the State can destroy.”

9/6/2013 First Things article on Marvin v. Marvin

http://www.firstthings.com/onthesquare/2013/09/the-case-that-destroyed-marriage